Cannabis in the Workplace South Africa: Positive Test vs Impairment

Positive for Cannabis. But Impaired at Work?
The test is positive. The employee says they used cannabis over the weekend. Your policy says “zero tolerance”. Is dismissal the next step?
That assumption could become an expensive mistake.
Cannabis in the workplace requires employers to distinguish between evidence of previous consumption and evidence that an employee is unfit to perform their duties. A positive result does not automatically answer both questions.
Private use and workplace responsibilities
South Africa’s constitutional protection of adults’ private cannabis use does not give employees permission to work while impaired or compromise workplace safety. Equally, employers should be cautious about using workplace policies to police lawful private conduct without a justifiable connection to the employee’s work.
In Enever v Barloworld Equipment South Africa, the Labour Appeal Court found against an employer that dismissed an office-based employee following positive cannabis tests without demonstrating impairment or a relevant safety risk. The judgment highlights the danger of applying a blanket rule without considering the employee’s actual duties.
A positive test does not tell the whole story
Cannabis can remain detectable after its intoxicating effects have subsided, particularly with regular use. Detection periods differ according to the person, pattern of consumption and testing method. Urine and blood results should therefore not be treated as interchangeable measures of current impairment.
A positive result may indicate previous use without establishing when consumption occurred, whether it happened at work or whether the employee’s ability to work was affected. In Enever, the Court expressly recognised that detecting cannabis does not, by itself, establish sobriety or impairment.
“Zero tolerance” still needs justification
Putting those words in a policy does not automatically make every dismissal fair. Employers must consider the rule, its justification, the evidence, consistent application and an appropriate sanction.
Safety-sensitive work requires particular care. Driving, operating machinery and other hazardous duties may justify stricter controls supported by an assessment of the risks. Recent Labour Court decisions demonstrate that outcomes differ: reinstatement was upheld in a cannabis-related matter involving a learner law enforcement officer, while dismissals involving machinery operators who tested positive for various drugs were upheld in another case. Context matters.
Record observations, not assumptions
Where impairment is suspected, a structured observation checklist can help managers document what they actually witnessed. Relevant observations may include unusually slow responses, difficulty concentrating, poor coordination, altered behaviour or unsafe actions.
Record the time, specific examples, witnesses and the employee’s explanation. Red eyes or slower movements alone are not conclusive: fatigue, illness or medication may offer another explanation. A checklist supports an assessment; it does not replace reliable testing, appropriate professional advice or a fair investigation.
If there is a credible safety concern, take reasonable steps to prevent exposure to danger while assessing the situation. A precautionary safety decision should not become an automatic finding of misconduct.
Review the policy before relying on it
An effective substance policy should distinguish between private use, consumption at work, impairment and breaches of justified safety rules. It should explain testing procedures, appropriate confirmation of results, confidentiality and how concerns will be investigated.
At Grok HR Solutions, we assist employers with reviewing substance policies, developing observation checklists and assessing the evidence before disciplinary action is taken.
Before a positive test becomes a dismissal letter, make sure the evidence supports the allegation—and the rule fits the risk.